Most financial planners and counselors advise their clients to maintain emergency savings of somewhere between 3 & 6 months’ living expenses. As I’ve mentioned in a previous article, saving 3-6 months’ expenses sounds so daunting that many people don’t know where to begin. When you throw in paltry returns on savings accounts, some folks might not even try. In fact, why bother when you can use a HELOC & tap into your home equity? After all, it’s pretty easy to tap into, and you can put your money to work in other ways, right?
Before you start, you might to think about what liquidity actually is and how to use it in emergency situations. You should also understand why having emergency savings still matters. While having access to a HELOC isn’t necessarily a bad idea, it’s important to understand that having one can be detrimental if you don’t use it properly. First, let’s discuss what liquidity is.
What does liquidity mean?
According to Investopedia, liquidity describes the degree to which an asset or security can be quickly bought or sold in the marketplace without affecting the asset’s price. The implication is that we’re discussing an asset that can be quickly sold in order to meet an emergent financial need. If you keep your emergency savings fund in a checking account, you don’t even need to sell anything. That’s as liquid as it gets. On the other end, being house-rich and cash poor means that most (or all) of your wealth is tied up in your house’s equity. Since you cannot quickly sell a house, most people do not consider a house to be a liquid asset.
Conversely, a HELOC is nothing more than having access to extra debt associated with your home’s equity. It might be prudent to use a HELOC to meet that same emergent financial need. However, it’s important to distinguish the difference between responsible use of debt and believing that the debt itself is an asset. Moreover, there are several things you should think about when it comes to home equity loans.
HELOC Point #1: You’re paying extra on that debt.
When you obtain a HELOC, you’ll most likely pay an origination charge. It might be a nominal amount, like $50 for a $10,000 line of credit. In terms of percentages, that’s still .5% for that first year…even if you don’t use it.
Also, you’ll pay a higher rate than your primary mortgage. That’s because your HELOC is a secondary debt to your primary mortgage. In other words, if your home goes into foreclosure, your primary lender is first in line to be reimbursed. Your HELOC lender will be repaid only after the primary loan is paid off. They charge extra for that additional risk.
In addition, HELOCs are usually tied to the prime interest rate. In other words, as interest rates rise, so does your HELOC rate. This is important to keep in mind…you cannot assume that you’re paying today’s interest rates for tomorrow’s emergency. If you’re the type of person who likes to run the numbers, you might find that this change alone could throw you off. Big time.
HELOC Point #2: It might not be there when you need it.
HELOCs are tied to…home equity. This may sound intuitive, but it’s an important consideration when you’re planning for the future. Although home values generally increase over time, they don’t do so in a straight line. When prices take a hit, that hit directly impacts home equity.
Let’s take an example of a hypothetical couple, Pat & Morgan. Their numbers, directly from a Bankrate article, are below:
Pat and Morgan bought a house in September 2009 for $172,000. They made a 20% down payment and refinanced 3 years later. In July 2014, they applied for a home equity line of credit.
Here’s how the bank calculates how much they can borrow:
Home’s current appraised value: $190,000
80% of appraised value: $152,000 ($190,000 x 0.8)
Amount Pat and Morgan owe on mortgage: $128,633
80% of home’s value minus amount owed: $23,367
The bank will give them a credit line of $23,367 or less.
What would happen if home prices went down 10%?
Home’s current appraised value: $171,000 ($190,000 x 0.9)
80% of appraised value: $136,800 ($171,000 x 0.8)
Amount Pat and Morgan owe on mortgage: $128,633
80% of home’s value minus amount owed: $8,167
That 10% dip in home prices erased $15,200 in borrowing power! Note: The HELOC decrease isn’t the same as the decrease in home value because you’re only borrowing against 80% of it ($19,000 x 0.8 = $15,200).
HELOC Point #3: Easy come, easy go.
Doesn’t it seem that if you work really hard and save up for a big purchase, then you appreciate it that much more? Conversely, if you don’t have to work as hard, then you don’t value it as much?
Imagine having to save $500 per month for 60 months to reach a $30,000 savings goal. You’re probably going to take really good care of the money that you accumulated over 5 years. At least, you’ll likely be pretty conservative in terms of what defines an emergency. And the good habits that you formed while reaching your savings goal will keep you on the right track.
On the other hand, imagine signing some paperwork, and a month later, you’ve got access to that same $30,000. Now, ‘emergencies’ pop up a lot more. Paying off the credit cards becomes something you’ll want to do as a matter of interest-rate arbitrage. If you don’t have a fixed budget, you pay ‘what you can’ each month. Doing this might not ever get you to pay off your debt. If you don’t take the time to learn where your money goes, a HELOC is probably not going to help you in the long run.
Why emergency savings still matter
You can summarize this statement with one point: Triple whammy. As discussed in my previous liquidity article, a triple whammy is when three external factors hit you in a relatively short period of time. This can be any three things that involve your money: family death or injury, accident, losing a job, long-term illness, etc. In the military, we usually don’t have to worry about losing our income until we transition. However, transitioning while moving and not having a job lined up…that’s two parts to a triple whammy. All you need is an accident or unplanned emergency to throw you off track. That’s where the difference between having savings and a HELOC really matters.
Let’s imagine you’re transitioning and trying to find a job. You’re relocating from overseas. While you’re on terminal leave, you end up in a car accident and have to replace your car. You’re now in a triple whammy. Let’s assume that six months later, your situation has stabilized. You spent $30,000 in relocation costs, living costs, and to buy a new car (insurance proceeds helped). However, your income is higher than when you were in the military, and things are generally trending up.
If you had a $30,000 savings account and zero HELOC: Your account is now zero. However, you’ve got a stable job, and you’ve done this before. You’ve got the confidence that with some fiscal discipline, you’ll be able to rebuild your emergency savings even faster than before (5 years at $500 per month).
If you had a $30,000 HELOC and zero savings: Your account is now zero. However, while you’ve got a stable job that’s paying more than before, you’re not sure where to begin. Is $30,000 in debt a ‘new normal?’ If so, at 4%, you’re paying $100 per month just to keep your balance from going up. Even if you wanted to pay it down, that $500 per month will get you back to zero in 67 months. That’s assuming a lot, to include:
- No annual charges
- No rise in interest rates
Using Bankrate’s calculator, if this HELOC had a nominal $50 annual fee and there was a .5% annual increase in interest rates, you’d still have a $4,099 balance. You wouldn’t pay off the HELOC until month 70, almost a year later. During this time, you’d have paid $3,921 in interest.
More importantly, unless you’re able to get your arms around your savings habits, you might not have the fiscal discipline to keep on this track.
Does this mean that having a HELOC is a bad thing?
Not at all. Used responsibly, a HELOC can be a very powerful tool. Having access to a HELOC while maintaining a zero balance can be a positive factor in your credit score calculation. HELOC interest is (usually) tax-deductible, which can lower your after-tax interest rate. This could be a factor in financing a large purchase, such as a car. Most importantly, it can serve as an additional cushion against unexpected emergency situations. However, since a HELOC isn’t an asset, you should not see it as a primary form of ‘liquidity.’